When Should You Look at Deck Remodeling, Resurfacing, or Replacement

Table of Contents

Deck remodeling and resurfacing can greatly enhance the appearance, functionality, and safety of your home. But when is the right time to consider these improvements? We will explore the key factors that indicate the need for deck remodeling, deck resurfacing, or deck replacement.

You will learn the signs to look for that indicate you might need to remodel or resurface your outdoor deck. If your deck is over 20 years old and showing wear, it might be time to consider replacing it for safety reasons.

What is the Difference Between Deck Remodeling and Deck Resurfacing

Photo of Elevated Deck with Black Railing and Steps

Deck remodeling and deck resurfacing are two different approaches to updating an existing deck, and they serve different purposes depending on the condition of the deck and the goals of the homeowner.

Deck remodeling is a comprehensive process that involves making significant changes to the structure, design, or functionality of a deck. You should consider remodeling if:

  • Changing the size or shape of the deck.
  • Adding new features such as built-in seating, pergolas, or lighting.
  • Replacing the railing system with a new design or material.
  • Upgrading the deck material from wood to composite or PVC for better durability and less maintenance.
  • Incorporating new stairs or levels to the deck.
  • Improving accessibility, by adding ramps or wider pathways.

Deck resurfacing, on the other hand, is a less invasive process that focuses on renewing the surface of an existing deck without altering its size or structure. This typically involves:

  • Removing and replacing the old deck boards with new boards. This can be with the same type of material or an upgrade to more durable composite materials.
  • Replacing the handrails and deck posts if they are worn out or if you want to update the style.
  • Sanding and refinishing the outdoor deck surface if the existing material is wood and still in good structural condition.
  • Repairing or replacing damaged or rotted structural components that are essential for safety but not necessarily altering the design of the deck.

How to Determine if You Need Deck Remodeling or Deck Resurfacing Services

Photo of Composite Deck with Railing and Ramp

These are the signs to look for to see if your deck needs attention. If you have a wood deck, and it is old, you will have a wide range of options for how to tackle the project. 

Look for these things to decide on a resurfacing or remodeling project:

1. Signs of Wear and Tear

Deck remodeling and resurfacing should be considered when signs of wear and tear become evident. An old deck that shows signs of wear, such as flaking paint, rotting beams, or rusted parts, requires immediate attention to prevent further damage. Cracked or splintered boards may need to be replaced, or a more substantial repair may be necessary.

2. Outdated Design

When considering deck remodeling and resurfacing for your home, it is important to address the issue of an outdated design. An outdated deck design not only detracts from the overall aesthetic appeal of your outdoor space but can also compromise its functionality and safety.

Traditionally, decks were box-shaped and just offered a place to sit outside on a raised surface. However, deck design, deck construction, and deck renovations have come so far in the past 10 to 20 years.

3. Faded or Cracked Paint

To address the issue of faded or cracked paint on your deck, it is crucial to assess the extent of the damage and determine the necessary steps for restoration or replacement. Faded or cracked paint not only detracts from the aesthetic appeal of your deck but also exposes the underlying wood to potential damage and deterioration.

4. Damaged or Rotted Boards

Addressing damaged or rotted boards on your deck requires prompt attention to ensure the structural integrity and longevity of your outdoor space. Rotted or damaged boards can pose a serious safety risk and compromise the overall stability of your deck.

5. Lack of Functionality

Are you experiencing signs of decreased functionality on your deck? If so, it may be time to consider deck remodeling or replacement to restore its usability and safety.

Here are some indicators that your deck’s functionality is compromised:

  • Uneven or unstable surface
  • Insufficient space
  • Inadequate features

Deck Remodeling vs Building a New Deck: Which Option Is Right for You?

Covered Composite Deck Wisconsin

When it comes to enhancing your outdoor living environment and deck space, you can opt for a deck remodeling project and building a new deck. Both options have their advantages and it’s important to make an informed decision based on your specific needs and preferences.

Factors to Consider

One important factor to consider when deciding between deck remodeling and building a new deck is the overall cost associated with each option.

Because deck remodeling involves making changes to an existing deck, it is typically less expensive than a new deck. The cost of remodeling will depend on the extent of the changes desired and the condition of the existing deck.

A new deck involves starting from scratch and constructing a brand-new structure. This option may be more expensive initially, but it allows for greater customization and the opportunity to incorporate modern materials and design trends.

Design Considerations

To make an informed decision between deck remodeling and building a new deck, it is crucial to carefully consider the design aspects that are important to you.

Deck remodeling provides the opportunity to incorporate innovative composite decking materials and finishes, allowing for enhanced appearance and flexibility in design and features. This option is ideal for individuals who wish to update the look and functionality of their existing deck without starting from scratch.

But building a new deck offers the chance to create a completely customized and unique outdoor living experience. With a new deck, you have the freedom to design every aspect of the structure according to your preferences. Want a curved deck? You got it. Want to replace those wooden deck railings with something more attractive? You can do it.

Starting fresh ensures that the deck meets current safety standards and provides an opportunity for transparent communication, expert recommendations, and quality craftsmanship.

We Use AZEK Decking in Resurfacing, Remodeling, and Replacement Deck Projects

When we resurface or remodel a deck, we want our clients to love their new deck and enjoy it for decades to come. For that reason, we always recommend building your new deck floor with AZEK decking. AZEK, a product line from TimberTech, provides many benefits for deck owners, whether we remodel your deck or simply resurface your current one.

From its extensive warranties to advantages in durability and natural resistance, AZEK offers many benefits for deck remodeling and resurfacing in Washington County, WI.

Here are some of the benefits:

  • Minimal Maintenance
  • Long-Lasting Durability
  • Lifetime Limited Warranty
  • Insect and Mold Resistance
  • Eco-Friendly Flooring Option  

Frequently Asked Questions

When Should I Resurface My Deck?

Resurface your deck when signs of wear, such as cracks, splintering, or fading, become apparent. Deck resurfacing enhances appearance, extends lifespan, and offers the flexibility to choose the right materials.

Is Remodeling a Deck a Good Investment?

Remodeling a deck can be a good investment for homeowners. It enhances outdoor living spaces, increases home value, and offers opportunities for popular deck design ideas. Choosing the right materials and proper maintenance are key for maximizing the investment.

Get Your Quote for Deck Remodeling and Resurfacing in Washington County, WI

When you’re ready to create your ideal outdoor living space, our professional deck designers and builders can provide expert deck remodeling and resurfacing in Washington County, WI. At Hometown Builders, we can help you enhance your property with composite decks that last for years and look great with minimal maintenance. Contact our team at (608) 772-1424 or get a free estimate when you need deck remodeling and resurfacing services in Washington County, WI.